The logo of the Melammu Project

The Melammu Project

The Heritage of Mesopotamia and the Ancient Near East


  The Melammu Project
  
   General description
   Search string
   Browse by topic
   Search keyword
   Submit entry
  
   About
   Open search
   Thematic search
   Digital Library
   Submit item
  
   Ancient texts
   Dictionaries
   Projects
   Varia
   Submit link
  FAQ
  Contact us
  About

  The Newsletter
  To Project Information >

 

Doctor in the patient’s house (1)

Printable view
Topics (move over topic to see place in topic list)

05 Scientific knowledge and scholarly lore




05 Scientific knowledge and scholarly lore



11 Language, communication, libraries and education



Keywords
Jews
medicine
omens
Period
No period specified
Channel
Jewish philosophers and scholars


Text
In a Talmudic anecdote there is described how a doctor (ˀsyˀ) came to the patient’s house and when seeing a gourd, the doctor departed saying that the angel of death resided in the house. The physician had observed a bad omen, indicating that the patient would die. The situation is similar to that described in the Babylonian Diagnostic Handbook, which begins by describing ominous signs which the incantation priest (or therapist) sees when he is on his way to the patient’s house, in order to render a prognosis. Omens include a variety of animals or handicapped persons, or even mundane objects such as a potsherd or kiln-fired brick, and many of these omens or signs will mean that the patient will die. The Ned. 49a passage ends with a Hebrew aphorism, that ‘it is prohibited to speak about it in front of an ignorant person’, which is an accurate reflection of a phrase often occuring in colophons of cuneiform tablets dealing with esoterica subjects, in which the scribe is warned against revealing the contents of the tablet to anyone not initiated or trained.


Sources (list of abbreviations) (source links will open in a new browser window)
Babylonian Talmud, Nedarim 49a
Diagnostic Handbook (Akkadian)

Bibliography

Geller 2004, 7Geller, Mark J. Akkadian Healing Therapies in the Babylonian Talmud. Preprint 259. Berlin: Max-Planck-Institut für Wissenschaftsgeschichte 2004. [PDF]

Mark Geller


URL for this entry: http://www.aakkl.helsinki.fi/melammu/database/gen_html/a0000926.php


Illustrations
No pictures


^
T
O
P